Make My Cake - New York

I picked up an order today. I must say that all of the staff at this location are very kind and welcoming. I had a long trip from this location to home and the staff professionally secured my order to make sure that there would be no problems with my order! I have been ordering cakes here every year, and will continue to recommend the Make My Cake family to all that I come across.

Good cakes(mostly, some are a bit dry), ok service. These people act like your lucky to have the right to pay for some cake from a lil whole in the wall shop lol. With that being said the cake is good.My favorites are the red velvet, the pineapple, strawberry shortcake, and key lime pie. I feel they lost a bit of touch since they moved from 116th but I’m hoping they fine new inspiration to innovate again.

Went in waited on by a very kind person. I love the sweet potato cheese cake, it is sooooo good. I haven't had it in 8 years and still taste soooooo gooooddd. I moved away and was here visiting so glad this place is still here. Small but the best deserts.

Lazy service! We wanted a simple message Happy 70th birthday Mom! on a birthday cake and they couldn 't even get that right. The message was missing the 70th , the most important part! How do you mess up such a simple message? SMH

I've always loved the red velvet cake. I travel from the Bronx whenever I want a good piece of cake. This is the place