Johnny's Pizza New Oxford

Everytime we go in to pick up our food everyone is always so nice and like to talk to you.

Best place in New Oxford for pizza and subs... Hard contender with pizza garden but Johnny's won me.. I'm bearable prices

This place is absolutely amazing I don’t know how people give bad reviews. Everything from pizza wings and Italian sub was on point. Absolutely amazing especially on a Saturday when things are busy.

These guys are great! haven't had a bad experience yet. The food is reallyyy good!I've had their pizzas and subs! currently my favorite is the cowboy steak.

Most fair guy in the food industry. 2 slices and a can of Coke for 3.95 ?! As of July 2024 ? AND it’s actually GOOD ! Plus unique pie flavors like Big Mac pizza and white pies that ACTUALLY have RICOTTA which 98% of pizzerias in Pennsylvania don’t even know to do that on a white ?! To Johnny Capellani this is your old friend whom you met through serving me pizza and subs when I used to have lunch breaks in your area. From a jersey boy to another God bless you brother. I passed by today and you were out putzing around on a motorcycle I heard anyways till next time