Casey's - New Lebanon

I picked up a slice of pizza and brought it home. I ended up having the whole thing. It was incredible—so delicious!

This gas station and convenience store really stands out. The high ceilings create a spacious feel, so it doesn’t seem like you’re entering a cramped space. It’s well-organized, making it easy to find what you need without feeling rushed or anxious. The customer service is excellent as well; the staff genuinely understand the importance of good service and treat everyone with respect. Overall, I have no complaints about this place, and I'd highly recommend it to anyone in Ohio.

This restaurant used to be a friendly place for my weekly visits, spending around $100. However, I've recently experienced some rudeness from the staff, which has made it uncomfortable. I understand that everyone can have an off day, but this has become a consistent issue. I don’t want to take my business elsewhere, but I will if the manager doesn't address the problem. It's concerning when my 7-year-old daughter also notices how rude the staff has become.

Have ordered pizza from there over 20 times since they opened. this sample size is large enough to define the casey?s is large. the few paints there was a problem that load staff did it right. I just got pizza from there, so I can't really check anything else.

Haven't been in yet, but I'm glad they're here, I haven't seen the gas prices stay the same for so many days in a row for 20 years!?? Finally tried the pizza, wasnt expecting much diff from other area pizza HOWEVER, it was VERY GOOD!!!??. I do like more garlic in the sauce, but even with that it was in my top 3. WELL DONE CASEY!