A Pizza History - New Castle

This is a large family-run pizza shop that serves incredible food. I absolutely love the dishes; everything is always fresh and delicious. Thank you, Pizza Story, for welcoming us every time we come as a family to eat with my wife. I highly recommend this restaurant to everyone, and their prices are just perfect!

I stopped by for a quick bite to satisfy a craving for cheese pizza, expecting not much. But wow! I can hardly remember having a crust as thin and crisp as this one (it rivals Frank Pepe's in CT). The cheese and tomatoes were fine, but for just $2, it was a fantastic slice! The seating is very limited, but this hardworking pizza place truly delivers on quality. Definitely give it a try!

I had a wonderful experience at this charming pizza shop! The pizza was delicious, the location was great, and the staff were exceptional. It was just what I needed during my travels across the country. I stumbled upon this place by chance, and I was not disappointed at all. I definitely recommend giving it a try!

Tony at Pizza History makes some of the best pizzeria food I've ever had. The regular pizza is delicious, but if you are lucky to get there early, you need to try the Chicago Deep Dish pizza. I've been looking for this near and far as I have it in Chicago, and that's as close to reality as Delaware will get it! It is so thick and fill your brain will tell you to stop on 1 slice, but it is so delicious, you ignore your better judgment and strength through layer 2 and 3! Truly, everything on the menu is amazing, but I also highly recommend the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak. This place makes it easy to support my local pizza shop and you should also!

I heard that you had great Pizza. Stopped in Friday night and picked one up. I was not disappointed. Crispy thin crust and great sauce at the right price. Will definitely stop again.