New Canaan Pizza

We are locals and frequent customers in this restaurant, but last night our family has an order about approx. 45 minutes in advance for only two items placed: a few tacos and some buffalo wings. Upon arrival, the staff seemed to do nothing, and only the preparation of our order began on our arrival, although it was placed almost an hour in advance. When we waited for our order to be prepared, we noticed that the employee who made the food did not wear a mask and coughed without capturing his mouth towards our food. After all that we go home to find that our wings have no sauce on them? They were just simple wings, despite the fact that we clearly ordered buffalo wings and in fact, the only item on your menu is buffalo wing (not simple wings or other flavors), so it was very clear that the staff did not make their work right and has our food without regard to what was clearly ordered or for what on the menu. Due to the lack of proper customer care and poor hygiene practices, we will not come back or recommend other locals to order food from here if you appreciate basic hygiene practices.

Good Pizza! I was 20, more than 65 years ago, before I had my first pizza. I was culturally deprived. For twenty years I dealt with New Canaan Pizza. I ordered what I thought of as a deluxe pizza, onions, peppers, black olives, mushrooms, and (double) sausage. Then the owner sold out and New Canaan Pizza closed but with a promise to re-open under new management. For months, I would stop to see if there was any progress toward reopening., No Joy. I tried every other pizza around. Still no joy. I gave up pizza. Finally it reopened. I was ecstatic. Ordered. Disappointed. Tried again. No joy, no pizza. Gave up pizza. Then came the pandemic. I was ordering groceries delivered and every fourth or fifth meal in. Now when ordering food in, pizza is the first choice and every third or fourth choice. So, I ordered from New Canaan Pizza. And, voila! It was deluxe pizza as I remembered it. I would order a large, eat two slices and carefully double-wrap and freeze the other six. Now, since the pandemic, there is not much to do. Every day, I spend at least twenty.minutes planning the evening meal. Last night, I planned pizza, with the left over ribs and pork tenderloin. When i went to the freezer this am I was disappointed to find no pizza. I went to Grubhub and re-submitted my last order for delivery at the cocktail hour. Boy is it good. Now, after ordering pizza from lots of places, I acknowledge that pizza is a matter of taste. Some people even like Dominoes. I recommend New Canaan Pizza. Give it a try.

The burritos are delicious. The carnitas especially. And I love Greek style pizza. I wish they would cook it a tiny bit longer even when I ask for well done but it's still great.

Been here before and knew the previous owners. Was worried that the pizza was going to be worse than before but I was pleasantly surprised with the quality. In some ways it is better than it was before, I had to find out who was working on certain days because one of the previous owners had a reputation for watering down the sauce while he was working but the new owners don't have this problem. Ordered the Bacon cheeseburger, veggie, chicken parm, and four cheese pizza. All were delicious and well worth the cost. Best pizza in New Canaan.

Just picked up my pizza! First time ordering from here! Called in for a large bacon and the chef made a pepperoni instead of bacon! But guess what!!! When I got home and opened the box it wasn?t even pepperoni! It was cheese! I paid for the extra topping and it had none! The large pie is very small. Not worth the money! Cheese on the pie tasted different. Not very good! Your not going to last too long in business if you make mistakes like this. I?m a very unhappy customer! Unfortunately, I Would not recommend going to this restaurant!