Pagoni's - Neenah

I live in Oshkosh, so I have to leave town to find decent pizza. I found this place by chance. The pizza is great! I just found out that most of their ingredients come from Chicago, fresh. And Chicago knows pizza!!! (I am a Wisconsinite, born and raised, but besides cheese, Chicago has the best food and restaurants in the Middle West) For quality, you simply cannot beat the price! The employees are also great. So you can expect a great customer service. I'm not gonna worry about getting any kind of pizza where I live. I'm going to Pagoni from now on.

The Sicilian pizza is amazing. It's very easy to stop eating full. Staff are always nice and respond to requests for the buffet. Sitting is limited and therefore it is not 5 stars. Take the seat to the seat side and expand! Also great renovations.

The Sicilian Pizza is amazing. It is very easy to keep eating past full. The staff are always nice and responsive to requests for the buffet. Seating is limited and that is why it is not 5 stars. Take the space to seating side and expand! Great renovations as well.

The only reason they get a second star is because the food was good enough to go back. Yesterday was our first visit to dine in and most definitely will be our last. Aside from the food taking unusually long to come out, one of the kitchen guys brings out our 4yr old 's Mac and cheese. He proceeded to tell us the bowl was hot and just came out of the oven. Are you freaking kidding me? You don 't put a lava hot ceramic bowl in front of a child and say, It 's hot, so be careful . Not good enough dude. My wife burned her finger on the bowl attempting to get our sons dinner onto a plate so he could actually eat it. As for my Chicago style Italian beef sandwich, when I ask for it dipped , there shouldn 't be any crunchy parts of the bread to be found. Also, when I ask for grilled onions, they shouldn 't be raw. Everything that came out of the kitchen was offered with a, Sorry about the wait . They were busy, but not to the degree they shouldn 't be used to for a Wednesday evening.

Barely any Cheese! Shame its Wisconsin! But hey i should already know aint no place like CHICAGO for Italian food!