Salt Pepper Pub - Nanticoke

The Salt and Pepper Pub on North Market Street in Nanticoke is an establishment that serves very good bar food, from sandwiches to burgers to wings...and a lot more. We arrived for our 6:30 p.m. reservation and sat out on the patio. There was only one other table occupied the entire visit. This really wasn't a good idea, however, since the outdoor dining area is next to a busy street, and the sound of the traffic at times drowned out the conversation. We probably could've sat indoors, since the restaurant was practically empty, but the weather was too pleasant to pass up. For an appetizer, I ordered a plate of 5 deep-fried braised beef short rib pierogi's. I would recommend the steamed version, as the dough was very hard. However, that was my mistake, and not the restaurant's. Should I visit again, I'll definitely choose the latter. Nevertheless,the beef was tender and delicious, and completely filled the pierogi. We also ordered the chicken parmesan sandwich, which was extremely tasty. The chicken was tender, the marinara sauce mild, and plenty of cheese with every bite. Along with our sandwiches, we ordered the white cheddar mac and cheese. I recommend eating half of your meal before digging in because the savory cheese sauce needs time to thicken for a more satisfying experience. The elbow macaroni was served al dente adding to an already perfect side. Also ordered were the truffle fries, which was delightful. The fries were crispy on the outside, and soft on the inside, and packed a lot of flavor. We had a fudge brownie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Overall, the dessert was average but it hit the spot after our entrees. The brownie was served warm, and the slightly melted ice cream added to a refreshing dish. All told, the Salt and Pepper Pub deserves a visit, but I wouldn't travel far to dine there. The food was very enjoyable, and would make an excellent casual night out...if you're in the area.

Yummy, very busy place but still got food quick : I liked their food options and enjoyed my pasta.

Went for dinner with my spouse about two weeks ago and wouldn’t go back again. The staff were very nice and the space has good ambiance but the wait and quality of food was unacceptable. Our appetizer was great but we waited another 45 minutes for our entrees and when mine arrived it looked and tasted basically inedible. My sandwich was cut in half and looked like it had been cooked 20 minutes before and then reheated. The bun was totally soggy and saturated on the bottom. The waitress noticed I hadn’t eaten much and asked if there was a problem and I told her why I was unhappy with it. She returned with an excuse from the cook that the coleslaw made the sandwich soggy but it didn’t have any on it. At that point, we had been there for almost an hour and a half and I just wanted to leave. She removed the entree from our bill, which I appreciate, but I wouldn’t go back until they fix their food service.

Not a great experience this time! Chicken was rubbery, rice was hard and not cooked. Dont think we will return! Told the waitress about the uncooked rice but didnt seem to matter! Was not offered a replacement and was still charged for it! This place went downhill!

Pleasantly surprised with the food and service when we did a spontaneous drop in late afternoon on a Saturday. Food was great and the service very good.