Sugar Creek Seafood - Nags Head

The coconut shrimp, fried clam strips, and onion rings felt overpriced and seemed like the type of frozen items that are simply dropped into hot oil. While there's nothing wrong with frozen foods, I wish Sugar Creek would consider using higher-quality ingredients. On a positive note, the salads and baked potato were decent. Overall, I found Sugar Creek to be too expensive for the mediocre quality of food offered.

Actually could be more of a 4.5. Great place. We were greeted quickly, given a 15 minute wait time--but called in about 10. We were waited on in good order and got all of our food in a timely fashion. We both had seafood entres and were happy with the presentation, content and price for the portion. We'll likely be back.

We come in about once a month, Sugar Creek never disappoints. If you have a chance to try the Shrimp and Grits DO IT. Ryan our waiter was on top of everything. Excellent service, amazing food as always.

We had the most incredible original seafood dishes. The seafood pasta platters were awesome! I got the wine, garlic and butter sauce and my husband got the fire roasted pepper marinara sauce. Both were scrumptious. Our family joined us and enjoyed the Hatteras clam chowder (I'll never go back to cream based again. , grilled tuna, crab and artichoke dip OH YUM!! The sunset was most incredible and a good reason they are known for great food and sunsets. Have to give a special shout out to our server, Ryan, who accommodated us and did an excellent job of magically answered to our every need. They were very busy and he went out of his way to be sure we had the best experience. Thanks Ryan!! Also, very pet friendly!!

We had a great experience at the restaurant, thanks to our wonderful server, Ryan. The establishment is also pet-friendly! I highly recommend bringing your entire group along when you visit.