Colton's Steak House Grill - Muskogee

Ordered the Philly Steak Sandwich with sweet potato fries. It arrived hot and fresh. The dasher Michelle was very kind. The sandwich was in my opinion perfectly made with just the right amount of onions, mushrooms, peppers and cheese. In was toasted as well! The sweet potato fries came with a delicious marshmallow-y dip!

Shrimp Alfredo was swimming in butter. Did not follow special instructions. Chicken was tough and overcooked. Very disappointed.

Unfortunately, my medium-rare steak was burned to a blackened crisp. I tried to eat it anyway, but you literally couldnt cut through it and the $28 steak went in the trash. In addition, Coltons left off a Caesar salad and the side of mushrooms. This is the second time weve had severe quality issues. ON THE OTHER HAND, Maggie (Dasher) went above and beyond and return to the restaurant to try to set it right and DDash customer service was helpful. Back to El Charro, Lopez, and Ginos for us ,

Caesar salad was so wilted and nasty Baked potato was so burnt it was not edible either had to throw both in the trash

Everything was good except the steak. For a $35 ribeye I expected more. It was like chewing on leather. Other cuts might be good but the ribeye was garbage! Also ordered a Cesar salad wich I did not receive. Put in a complaint with DD and got a refund. So they made it right.