Sully's Pizza Calzones - Mukilteo

The pizza and calzone at this restaurant are incredibly delicious! Despite being busy preparing for a last-minute event, they still managed to seat us and were very accommodating. I particularly enjoyed the gluten-free crust, which was cooked perfectly (not undercooked or too crispy). We will definitely be returning in the future!

My husband and I came for dinner. We ordered the focaccia Pesto cheese bread as an appetizer, the greek salad bbq chicken calzone to share. While the restaurant is small the entrance isn’t entirely clear, it is quaint. The proximity to the water the view adds to the appeal. There was a sign upon entering stating staff shortage due to covid. Which was apparent as the young man working was the greeter, waiter bar tender. There were two young girls in the kitchen area preparing the food. The service was very good. The food was average. Honestly, I felt that we could have received the same quality of food at a fast food place for at least half the price. The appetizer was tiny. The salad was average. The calzone was difficult to bite/cut through the crust had very little inside. Perhaps, it was the haste hurried manner in which the young girls in kitchen seemed to be in that resulted in a quality of food that lacked any originality. Nothing against the girls who prepared the food as they always seemed to be smiling and working to the best of their ability. But for a quaint, locally owned restaurant in such a prime location, I had higher expectations. I probably will not be back.

Amazing pizza. Really thick and oily. I loved it. The team there are really cool and welcoming.

I arrived at the restaurant at 8:30, hoping to order some pizzas. However, I was told that the kitchen was closed already. Despite the open sign still being on and the restaurant supposed to be open until 9, they had already shut down the kitchen. I usually enjoy Sully's pizza, but this experience has made me hesitant to order from here again. It was disappointing to see the entire kitchen cleaned and shut down by 8:30. The employee who informed me of this hurried out right after, seeming to have other priorities. This is not a good way to operate a business.

My party and I visited this restaurant on a recent Saturday and were greeted warmly by the server. We got there about 45 minutes before closing time and were informed that they did a strict closing at 9. This wasn't an issue for us as we happily accepted the challenge, knowing we wanted a quick meal. We ordered appetizers, pizza, and each had two drinks, and managed to leave by 8:55. Our mission was accomplished, and we were able to allow the staff to leave at the time they wanted. The food and drinks were great as always, and we are looking forward to returning for another delicious meal.