Paul Eddy's Pizza

I’ve lived in Hamden over 30 years and this is the first time I ordered from Paul Eddy’s. I didn’t realize what I was missing. It was great.

I have been a fan of Paul Eddy's for quite some time. It is our go to pizza delivery in Hamden, through the Slice app. But last night...was BAD. Ordered and paid (as we always do via Slice at 5:30PM. App showed 6:20PM delivery. About right. 7:10PM, pizza still not here. Contacted Slice customer support, via their app, they stated the shop wasn't answering the phone. 10 minutes later (7:20PM, one hour later than stated, and almost TWO hours since ordering , our 2 pizzas arrived. Those pizzas were barely (and I mean BARELY warm, room temp at best. Both crusts were completely charred BLACK, all the way around. (I am a fan of an overdone crust, but this wasn't over done, this was BURNT. And because they were more cold than hot, VERY chewy, and not at all enjoyable. The large mozzarella cheese, half sausage barely any cheese on it, and a light sprinkling of sausage, maybe a dozen or so small sausage crumbles. Very disappointing. My wife and son both stated, we may have to try other local pizza places in Slice in the future.

The food is great and love the turnovers. But the pizza is a 3 at best for me. I'm old school this wasn't myvstyle of pizza.

One of the best pizzas of all time! I now live in Austin TX and routinely crave a slice from here. Been coming since 2001! Was served this every Friday at school for lunch and was a local customer for 18 years. One of the only places that is a must go when I come home. The clam casino is offf the charts.

Excellent food and service. Staff is very genuine and friendly. Highly recommended.