Eatalian Pizza - Mount Forest

The pizza was disappointing. I ordered extra cheese but barely received any. The wings tasted like they were store-bought, which was a letdown. Overall, it felt like a waste of money. I ended up throwing half of it away. The crust was too doughy and undercooked. Quite frankly, it was a complete waste.

The pizza here is excellent, with consistent quality that surpasses what you'd typically find in a small town. In my opinion, it's far superior to Pizza Hut or Domino's. The pick-up service is efficient, and the value on their specials is exceptional. I wholeheartedly recommend the pizza; however, I haven't tried the other menu items or the delivery service yet.

The pizza and pickles were incredibly delicious! I ended up going back two times within just a few days because I couldn't get enough.

Moved here 5 months ago. Been loyal to eatitalian since. Once sometimes twice a week. Last time no cheese or any sauce on the wings or the extra 2 dips that I paid for. A hour later he shows up and This time no pops with delivery special and not “cold”but barely warm pizza. I live 3 minute drive (google maps)up the street! on the same street! called to complain the guy said we will bring a new pizza(no pop) and I need to return the one we got. So my 2kids are not able to eat until it gets here. I WILL NEVER ORDER HERE AGAIN.

This used to be the go-to pizza place in town. It's still really good, but I did drop it from a 5 to 4 stars. The topping have been reduced, and something is just a bit different with the new ownership. Also, it's locally and privately owned...not a chain....that's a plus. Still one of the better if not best place for pizza in town. Great multi-pizza deals.