Mi Casa Mexican - Monteagle

The exterior of the restaurant may be misleading, but once inside, my wife and I discovered a spacious and impeccably clean dining area with a lively bar that had a festive and relaxing atmosphere. The...

The food and service at this restaurant were fantastic. The ambiance was perfect and the server was extremely friendly and attentive. The chips and salsa were exceptional and I couldn't get enough of them.

The service was excellent, quick and efficient! The cheese dip was amazing. The restaurant was very clean and comfortable.

Driving by several times, we were never sure if this place was open or maybe just didn't exist anymore due to the unkempt nature of the outside. Looked it up and saw it was rated 4.4 and actually open so thought we would try it. Went for lunch today and were seated at an odd table in a booth that was so low, it touched out knees. They did move us after we asked. Looking around, the place was just dirty and nasty. Cob webs everywhere, the glass sign on the wall in the booth area was splattered with who knows what and peeling at the bottom. The place was just run down. The food was pretty subpar. I ordered a trio plate with your pick of several items listed on the menu so I asked for a burrito, chalupa and an enchilada. What I got was a tostada and 2 things that may or may not have been enchiladas. They were all chicken that was ridiculously salty. My husband ordered a combo plate and even though there was no chicken in his dish, he ended up with some type of chicken thing that probably was my chalupa. He agreed that the chicken was super salty! There wasn't an actual bill, we just went to the counter and he calculated our two items, which took longer than it actually should have for just two items, and came up with $28. Now my item was only supposed to be $8.99 and I didn't know what my husband's was until I asked him after we left, which was $14. So with only those two items, it should have been only $23. I wasn't in the mood to argue so I let it be. Overall, I wouldn't recommend or go back. If you're willing to take your chances, make sure you know what you're paying for when you pay the bill. Food: 2 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 3

The outside doesn’t do this place justice. The food is fantastic and the prices are low. Will definitely go back anytime we are in Monteagle! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5