The Olde Erie Pub - Middletown

Everything was AMAZING !!! Shrimp scampi, broiled lobster tail, steamed little neck clams, eggplant tower !! I was a wonderful lunch !! Thank you Maria and Linda. I brought my Mom for her belated Mother's Day lunch and she loved it !!!

Always a Great Time, decades of fantastic Italian Specialties. Generations of serving the community and catering to private events. Thank You JoJo, Linda, Maria and family...

Our waiter, Scot, was fantastic, and the restaurant itself is beautiful. The food was absolutely delicious. It was a fun and enjoyable experience overall. I went back for a second time, and it was just as amazing!

If I could give this restaurant more than five stars, I absolutely would! Maria Donna, I can't thank you enough for the outstanding care and excellent service you provided for my mother's celebration of life. The dining room you recommended was perfect for our small group of 25, and the ambiance was unmatched. The food was both delicious and plentiful! Maria, your warm professionalism eased all my worries, allowing me to relax and enjoy the company of our guests. The service was exceptional—your team was always available when we needed you but never intrusive. Thank you for everything! You are, without a doubt, the best!

Always delicious! My family and I have been visiting this restaurant for nearly thirty years. The food consistently impresses, the menu is fantastic, and the specials are always unique and tasty. The owners are also very welcoming. Plus, the holiday decorations are always exceptional!