Basille's - Middletown

This is the best pizza in the area, and some of the best pizza I’ve ever had (and I’ve had a lot of pizza)! I moved to Middletown recently and have tried several places before settling on this one — it’s perfect! The sauce, cheese, pepperoni, crust, so delicious and perfectly made. A nice bonus, the folks who work here are also very friendly.

Very expensive , a 5 piece chicken wings 15.99 and i waited 20 min for my french fries after they brought me the chicken wings . those two things and a water bottle $25 ridiculous… make sure to check the seasonings on the side ?‍ definitely will not go back !!Food: 2/5

When you walk in say hello to Tommy and Joy,two of the nicest people you wanna meet. The sicilian slice is awesome thick and filling. The crust on the regular slice is light and savory. Just a great place with great pizza.Food: 5/5

Seriously. Having lived in Monmouth County and the are for over 35 years, this is hands down the best pizza. I stopped for a slice the other day going to the wine store next door and really enjoyed the crisp but also flavors of the slice. Then I went back today to see if it was a fluke and got a 2 large pies, one plain and one with sausage and mushrooms for the family. Beautiful. And the price was very reasonable if not less expensive than anywhere which has been reviewed, by 20 to 30 . Awesome job Gents.

Delicious pies. Right amount of cheese. Great sauce. They did dress my salad when I asked for dressing on the side but still deserves a 5 star.