Disappointment Diner - Middletown

Despite being a new building, Athenian Diner II exudes a classic diner vibe, from the cakes and pies behind glass to the neon and the candy below the counter at the checkout register. I came in for a slice of pie at night and was not disappointed, though what I ended up ordering was cake and not pie. The menu was massive. If I had the time and metabolism I'd love to explore it. Recommended.

Wow, what a huge menu and breakfast is served all day. Coffee is great. Right up front in Middletown Plaza.

In keeping with a long standing tradition, I had the opportunity to join the happiest group of people I have ever known, who all share a meal together every Friday night at this beautiful establishment. The food here is amazing! The service is wonderful, and the staff makes everyone feel comfortable and welcome, and they do a great job of getting everyone served as quickly as possible, and without any mistakes. They make it look easy, but behind those doors to the kitchen, it's clear the are working very hard to prepare all these meals. I will add photos of the desserts when I go again next Friday, as they looked absolutely amazing as I walked by them on my way out, but I just could not help myself with my dinner, and I did not leave enough room dessert. All of the dishes that came out to the table at the same time, and they all looked so good, we began to joke about trading plates with one another. Each dish is perfectly portioned to completely satisfy every customer. My only issue Friday night, since it was my first time at the Diner, was with deciding what I wanted off of the menu; the menu is so large and all-inclusive, they have every type of cuisine, for any meal, breakfast, lunch, dinner, snack, dessert, etc., and it's all available at any time of the day or night. You cannot go wrong with choosing this Diner for any large get-together with friends/family, or for date night, or even for a quick meal for yourself. As I mentioned, I will be returning this Friday night, and I plan to make this tradition a part of my life going forward.

Diner was located in a very prime location in middletown. The atmosphere of the place was good. The waitress were really polite. Our waitress Alexander was very sweet. We ordered the chicken parm , we got a hair but they immediately took it and replaced it with a new meal. Also ordered the avacado salad with the salmon Which was well done per request. For dessert we tried the Canoli which was good too. Had a good experience.

Pictured is a single pancake and a bacon ham omelet with fries. The food here is great comfort food. Didn't feel like making breakfast on the rainy morning so I went out to get some breakfast food. Succeeded to fill my craving. Been going here for a while and never had a bad dish. Good service/seating area.