Carvel Ice Cream - Middle Island

As is this store's custom, everything was excellent tasting and very carefully packaged. This is one of the best Carvel's on the Island and I highly recommend.

This store is very consistent. They always get the order right, they make it quick and overall make it a very pleasant experience. It's always exceptionally tasty too. Kudos to the workers at the store for a job well done. Highly recommend this location.

Unedible and water down. The ice cream machine must've been broken. Called the store Alex was extremely rude and unhelpful. What a disappointment we usually order there a lot. Hopefully he won't be there next time we try to order. luckily DoorDash refunded my items.

Always good but they changed menu and now we can no longer order soft serve ice cream cups (other than a sundae).

Chocolate thick shake wasn't very thick at all. I was very disappointed.