Pagliacci Pizza - Mercer Island

The staff at the counter were very nice, but the restaurant was dirty. The floor was sticky and covered in food, and all the tables and chairs were dirty as well. We arrived around 4 pm, before the dinner rush. The salad was fresh and the crust on the pizza was good, but the pizza itself was too greasy. We were hoping for better quality. The service was decent, but the atmosphere was not great. Overall, the dining experience was disappointing. Price per person was between $30-50. Food was rated 3, service 4, and atmosphere 1.

I really enjoyed the spicy chicken and gorgonzola and tomato pizza slices. It was convenient to buy them by the slice. However, COVID has affected this place, as the toppings were less than before. We were grateful to use their terrace with the gas heaters to stay warm on a cold night while enjoying our pizza.

The salads were smaller than expected. I don't recommend it, in my opinion it's a rip off - getting less for more. There are many other pizza options available, I suggest trying Big Mario instead. Seattle Half Clip seems to be digging into their customers' pockets.

I ordered a large pizza and a small salad, and was informed that there would be a 1.5 hour wait, which was not unexpected for a Sunday night. Surprisingly, the order was ready 30 minutes early, although I was not prepared for it. Upon arrival, I had to wait 10 minutes to receive the pizza, which had been sitting for another 10 minutes, and an additional 10 minutes for the salad. By the time I got home, the pizza was cold and soggy, and missing two ingredients. After calling to address the issue, I returned to pick up the missing toppings and received a small pack of dry cookies as compensation. I would have rated this experience 1 star, if not for the cookies. Once reheated, the pizza was delicious, but I still feel it was overpriced for the quality.

The pizza and salads at this restaurant are delicious. The pint of ice cream is a bit pricey at $10, but it's so good that it's worth it. The only thing lacking is some hot sauce for the pizza. The service was excellent, with a rating of 5 out of 5, and the atmosphere was also great with a rating of 5 out of 5. Overall, a great spot for dinner.