Pop's Frozen Custard - Menomonee Falls

The best custard! Excellent service, friendly employees. A bit expensive, but I guess you at least get what you pay for here!

My family has been going to Pop’s for years since we moved to the Falls. It’s always been good, with good service and prices that were decent, but not great. I thought the slightly higher prices were justified because it’s a small business the kind of place my family and I like to support. Tonight, I stopped in because I was craving custard after I had dinner at home. I was SHOCKED to see that a “Snow Storm” was $8.99! A Google review from just three weeks ago had a picture of the menu, showing the same item at $6.79. Of course, inflation touches everything. But this just feels exploitative. Because I was already there and don’t want to spend any more time, I reluctantly ordered my custard, but, disappointingly, that will be the last time I stop at Pop’s. There are a lot of other options. Maybe other folks can spend that kind of money at a place like Pop’s they were busy tonight but it won’t be me. The service was still good, food and atmosphere are okay. But the value just isn’t what it used to be, so overall, 2 Stars.

There's more toppings than ice cream to their sundaes

This place has been around forever and it's proven amazing since day 1. Love Pops.

We were in the area and a hot and humid day DEFINITELY called for custard! Since we have not tried this location, it was an easy decision. While walking in, someone was carrying out onion rings that made it onto my order because they looked great! The onion rings and curds were very good. The huge selection of custard was difficult to decide but we were able to finally narrow down our choices. The root beer float custard and cotton candy blend were good choices! The workers were very friendly even though it was very hot and they were pretty steady with customers. This place is worth a stop, and then go back again! Love the look of the place also.