Ernie's Ice Cream - Mahwah

I tried the Cookie Monster-flavored ice cream, but there wasn't much cookie dough or cookie pieces in it. It mostly tasted like blue-colored vanilla ice cream. I was a bit disappointed.

This ice cream is absolutely delicious! The coconut flavor is fantastic, and the peanut butter isn't overwhelming at all. It's hands down the best ice cream in town!

The ice cream is fantastic, but I recently ordered three quarts for $55 and was disappointed to find that the top 1.5 inches were empty and there were significant gaps along the sides. This issue isn’t a one-time occurrence; it has been getting worse recently. This experience has pushed me to my limit, and I won’t be ordering from Ernie’s through DoorDash anymore.

Awesome ice cream stand with amazing array of unique and delicious flavors. Lots of soft serve options (mix-in, I believe, but still! . Friendly staff. I had Nutella and Coconut, half and half. Delicious!!!

Their ice cream is outstanding! It has an amazing flavor and the portions are very generous.