Salvatore's Tomato Pies (Madison)

Can’t beat $12 one topping pies on Tuesdays! We literally get this 3-4x a month. Love their bacon, fresh jalapeño, Gorgonzola, pepperoni, or fig as the topping

I was visiting relatives and decided to treat everyone to Salvatore’s. This place came so highly reviewed, I thought we had to try it. We ordered around 6:30 and the wait to pick up was 50 minutes. Super long, but I thought it surely would be worth the wait.We arrived at scheduled pickup time and called up for curbside. We were told “I’ll grab your order and be right out.” 15 minutes later, I decided to go in just to see if I could grab it myself and head out since we had hungry family members waiting. Someone saw me and checked on the order and told me they’re running behind, but it would be about 5-10 more minutes and he would bring it to our car. Another 15 minutes later, my boyfriend heads back in to see what the deal is. He sees our 2 pizzas just sitting on the counter...getting cold. They finally give him our 3rd pizza and we leave after 40 minutes of waiting.When we get back to our place, which is not even 10 minutes away, the pizza was cold. I paid $70 for a 16 inch and 2 10inch pizzas. I mean if you’re going to charge those kinds of premium prices for pizza, then the least you can do is keep the pizza warm for carry out customers, whom you don’t seem to prioritize at all. I should not have to microwave fresh pizza after a <10 minute drive. Really disappointed and frustrated by that entire experience.

As a first time customer, my wife and i came to Madison on a mini stay cation. Staying at a local hotel downtown, Sals came recommended by numerous people at the hotel. So going off that we gave Sals a try. Only a block downt the street, we ordered our order at 630p. The time of arrival was noted to be around 730pm. We were ok with the wait time knowing how recommended this place was. We did not get our order till an hour after our suggested arrival. AN HOUR!!. Our food was cold. Both pizza and appetizer. I do hope that this place gets better communication or maybe more help if this place wants to keep their reputation in tact. PS im sure the food does taste better when its fresh and not been sitting under a heat lamp for some time.

This is the only place in Madison that I choose to order from if I have a craving for a pizza-like thing (these are definitely tomato pies, and some don't even have tomato sauce). They're are spectacular hipster creations that I couldn't even dream of. Who thinks of putting 4 different mushrooms on a pizza? The ingredients are to die for and they make even a basic creation mouth-watering. They are fantastic with allergies/diet restrictions and I always feel comfortable ordering here. They're a little expensive, so I won't order this for a party, but I will definitely order a whole pie for myself.

They use local farm fresh ingredients. The pizzas and other menu items are top quality. Salvatore Pizza is on my Mount Rushmore of best pizza ever.