Pizza Suprema - Lutz

Called for order and was told 25 min. Arrived and pizza was sold. No answer, no solving problem. Don't waste your time. NY pizza is better.

Do yourself a favor order from here! My husband and I dropped in for lunch randomly on Saturday 2 quick slices a drink. Wow! We got a slice of the white pizza and a slice or what looked like bruschetta on top (idk the name, we just pointed in the glass case) SO GOOD! Quick service and very friendly. The kind of place where you feel like you know the people even though it was my first visit. Will be back again and order exclusively now for our delivery too.

Pick this place if you want rude service after you let them know their food was disgusting. I ordered the sausage sandwich because it was late and closest place around. Got it home and it felt like the bread was soaked in water it was the soggiest most disgusting sandwich I have ever had it was not even edible. It was to late to get a remake so was offered a credit. But then they magically couldn’t find it. If you like soggy gross sauce this is the place for you oh and if you really appreciate rude people over the phone it’s definitely the place for you!

I've been there 3 times and I had the Philly cheese steak , a slice of supreme pizza ?, chicken parmesan and I can say it was all great oh yes I had their wings just not enough sauce on them but I give a pass because they were busy ?

THIS PLACE IS SIMPLY THE BEST! Pizza Suprema is my go to when it comes to local NY Style slices. I have loved their lunch special (2 slices a drink) for years and try to get it whenever I can. Their customer service is impeccable and no matter what the day of the week it is they always serve greatness. Including tonight where I stumbled in after they were closed and kind gentleman didn’t turn me away like anyone otherwise would. Instead he asked if could wait a few minutes and prepared me a personal of my favorite white pizza. I’m beyond thankful as I just finished church practice and I was craving a slice. I’m thankful for his kindness, despite me not being the nicest person to deal with hearing that they were closed at first. This gentleman made things right and blew me away with his hospitality. I now know the correct time they close, and will continue to give them my business for as long as I can eat pizza ? These guys are the best!