Gino Tony's Italian Eatery

This is likely the best vegetarian restaurant in Lake George. They offer a fantastic selection of vegetarian dishes. I highly recommend their vegetarian pizza, and you absolutely must try their tiramisu! You can tell it’s expertly made, as the coffee gently seeps out when you cut into the cake. It’s moist and perfectly balanced in flavor. The service is excellent, too!

The service was abysmal, the food was terrible, and everything was extremely overpriced—not genuine Italian cuisine at all. The restaurant was understaffed, and we had to wait a long time before anyone came to our table throughout the evening. The dishes were skimpy on sauce and everything was so dry, it felt like it had been sitting in the kitchen for a while. I really don’t understand the positive reviews; it seems like some people don’t know what true Italian food should taste like. I didn’t expect the best meal, but I did anticipate polite customer service and a dish that truly represented its name. Everything felt like it came from a can or a box, with no clear understanding of what they were cooking. It's hard to believe anyone could mess up a simple penne alla vodka. Save yourself the trouble and choose a different restaurant to avoid spending a small fortune on food that is neither decent nor a true representation of the dishes on the menu.

This restaurant is not up to par for an Italian dining experience. Both of our soups were served lukewarm, even though our server assured us they were hot and needed to be handled with care. We had to send them back. The Italian Platter was passable but could certainly be better, even for a tourist destination. The cannoli was hollow in the middle, but it was the best dish we had during our meal.

Food was delicious and plenty to eat and reasonably priced My only reason for given it one star was due to the canoli dessert. We ordered choc chip cannoli and it had maybe 5 small choc chips in it and was too sugary/floury. When the waitress brought over the cannoli I even said to her we ordered a choc chip cannoli because none could be seen and she said it was choc chip.

I was a little skeptical of trying this place we've never been here before. Lake George isn't famous for it's food and we've ran into some really bad restaurants in this area before. Since the Adirondack Pub was way too busy that night and we've already been to the Moose Tooth enough times already, this was the place we decided on. Outdoor seating is always nice. Other reviewers mentioned that the furniture isn't top of the line and they're correct. However, outdoor seating in the Lake George village is a major plus. I don't really think this place was meant to be a gourmet restaurant. So I'm guessing those complaining of the quality of the outdoor chairs also complain that there are no cloth napkins at McDonald's. We started out with some drinks. I ordered the Long Island and my girlfriend ordered a Margarita. Both were made very well. Mine wasn't mixed completely, but a little stir solved that problem. Excellent quality. Since this was an Italian restaurant, I went and ordered a personal pizza for myself. Which was a mistake on my part because the Blue Cheese Bacon Cheeseburger that my girlfriend ordered was mind blowing and I wish I had ordered that instead for myself. Don't get me wrong though. The pizza was still good. It's not what I would call NY style though. It's thin pizza, but has a very nice crunch to it. Overall, we left this place very satisfied and will definitely be returning in the future. Highly recommended.