Sweet Pete's - Key West

One of the best key lime cakes in the Florida Keys! We ordered the chocolate-dipped key lime cake, and it was absolutely delicious. We sampled three different places for the key lime cake, and this one was definitely one of my favorites!

This bakery is fantastic for take-away key lime cake! They have a lovely location with a cozy outdoor area where you can enjoy your purchases right on the spot if you’re eager to taste them before heading out. The staff was incredibly friendly, and I would certainly come back!

I went on a girls' day trip to the Keys and had to stop here for the best cake! The seating, both inside and outside, was lovely. I tried the Coconut Key Lime Pie and the original Key Lime Pie, and both were absolutely incredible! I couldn't have asked for a better experience than enjoying amazing cake with my best friend while watching roosters roam the street.

Very good natural strawberry ice cream. The pies were ok, nothing special. The staff wasn’t super friendly.

The key lime pie is great. Believe me I've made it a life long mission to try this amazing mix of flavors everywhere I can. Tart with a sweet crunchy crust. If they put key limes in it then this store sells it.