Pepper Pot Island Cafe - Key West

I couldn’t stop and snap a photo of the jerk chicken sandwich before devouring it. It was SO BOMB! The flavor of the chicken was unlike anything I’ve had, and it was moist and delicious, topped with the slaw on a tasty bun.The potato salad side was great too. Not to mention I sampled a green hot sauce that was totally unique and delicious! Spicy, fruity, and vinegary!The amazing flavors still linger in my mouth and I encourage everyone to taste this food!Service was quick and friendly as well!

You know the exhilaration of finding that hole in the wall restaurant that dazzles you with authentic home cooked food? Pepper Pot is that place. I had a vegetarian roti with thinly sliced butternut squash, spinach and dhal. So good! My husband had the best jerk chicken. Don’t miss this spot. Amy and Shane are putting the love into their cooking.

I a town with many good restaurants, this is one that is an unexpected wonder.

Really perfect. Small, counter service place with simple, delicious food. Not overpriced. Very friendly staff of just a couple. Super comfortable place to grab a quick bite.

Saw the reviews and decided to go. Excellent food. First time trying goat meat. It was nice and tender.Really nice staff too.