Big John's Pizzeria - Key West

Wife and I had the 2 slices and soda special. Very close to NY city experience. Daughter had the chicken fettuccine and said it was amazing.

The service was lacking, but I don't attribute that to the staff; it's just the layout of the restaurant. The food was decent overall. The pizza wasn't cut completely, the garlic knots had a bit too much Parmesan, but they were still tasty. The classic fettuccine Alfredo was pretty good, although the noodles were a tad undercooked, which didn’t bother me too much. It's a typical pizza place—neither bad nor exceptional.

Super fresh and hot pizza straight from the oven. Had veggie pizzas today after the rainy Christmas Eve and loved every bite of it.

So nice to find a more traditional Italian restaurant. You can taste the real garlic, basil, Alfredo sauce. Pizza and pastas...top notch

It might have been an off day, but the staff seemed disengaged. When my order got mixed up due to a language barrier, they did replace it, but their demeanor suggested they weren't thrilled about it. They weren't rude, but their body language, especially when delivering the new pizza, indicated otherwise. Overall, it was just an average experience.