The Islander - Key Largo, Tavernier

Don’t waste your time coming to this restaurant!!! It’s a private community and is not open to the public. Google maps should remove this.

Great spot on Ocean Reef for fish, steak, and their Greek salad is awesome.Highly recommend this location and Giannis for quality service and dinner.

Probably the best place to eat at ORC. Consistently good quality food and decent service.

If I could give this place no stars I would. I called ahead to reserve a table and was told we could just walk in and sit at the sushi bar. I specifically asked if they were open to the public and was told it would be no problem.We drove 30 min to the area to find a gate house and couldn’t get in. I called back to the restaurant and spoke to a manager and was told that this is an exclusive resort and there staff doesn’t know to ask if we are staying on the property. It should be noted on their website that this restaurant is private and cannot be accessed. Very very disappointed !!!! That’s ok. We found a much better restaurant that happily took our money and gave us better service than the Islander ever could have provided.

One of our favorite spots on the Reef. Amazing sushi. Incredible fish. Random, but the hashbrowns are a must. Good wine selection. Solid cocktails. Relaxing atmosphere. What's there not to love?Vegetarian options: A few.Kid-friendliness: Very family friendlyParking: Golf Carts only.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access