Jericho Cider Mill

Best place ever for fresh cider and pies. Tried their apple crisp last week....it's my new favorite.

My children's favorite place for apple donuts ? and for me the hot apple cider ?

Sent a message and pictures of this disaster through their website and a FB message. No response. Very expensive pie. Apple pieces chopped/minced. No slices. Sour. No sort of juice. Like ingredients were missing. Crust was not over baked, just dry inside. We live too far to have returned it. This place used to be good.

Love their cider, pies and preserves. Also bought some cider donuts on a whim and they were lousy. Still willing to give them 5 stars for the great other stuff.

The prices are quite high, but unfortunately, everything from the cod to the donuts and pies is below standard. The apple crumb pie was particularly disappointing—it had little flavor aside from a cloying sweetness and was also undercooked. Overall, not worth the cost.