Miley's Old Inn - Jamestown

TAKE NOTE, yelpers, foodies, and burger enthusiasts. This place is worth a field a trip if you are even semi nearby, but definitely not one to miss if you ever find yourself in Jamestown, NY. My mouth waters and my heart misses that menu featuring FORTY+ signature burgers, all 1/2 lb. USDA Choice ground chuck and sirloin (unless described differently) all uniquely creative. And if that isn't enough in the options department for ya, they also offer 60+ different wing sauces along with other traditional bar menu favorites. From the outside, it looks a little divey, the area isn't super pretty, there's an abandoned gas station across the street. Get past that and get inside where it's an inviting, neighborhood bar atmosphere with an exciting menu at reasonable prices.

Divey outside just outside of a bad part of town but I'd say it's still in the green. Food and drinks are great here tonight. Really good wings and burgers, they start serving lunch just after opening at 11:30am.

Decided to stop in after driving by for years then having it pop up on my Yelp feed. So glad it did! Pulled up with my sister on a Friday afternoon around 3:30 to find street parking only, but there was plenty along with an abandoned gas station across the street that patrons were using. We walked in to find about 6 guys around the bar and the dining room empty. Asked the bartender if they were serving and he said, yea we're between cooks right now, but I can cook ya something. Well he didn't disappoint. They offer about 60 different wings flavors. They allow you to mix up to 3 flavors on a 12 wing order. Also, to my sisters delight they allow you to get all flats or all drums for a $1 up charge. We both ordered a sampler of wings, can't remember all of the flavors, but I would definitely re order the medium Cajun Parmesan and my sisters zesty raspberry was very hot, but very good. The wings were perfectly crispy with the right amount of sauce. I'm not a huge blue cheese fan, but there's was delicious. We also got a basket of homemade shoestring cut fries that were also cooked to perfection! We will definitely be back to try the burgers. Maybe on a Monday or Wednesday between 5 pm and 11pm when they advertise their burgers are $3.99. By the time we left the dinner crowd was filing in and a waitress had came in. She was friendly and as was the bartender that severed/ cooked for us.

Great wings. Both dry and wet. Beer on tap and excellent burgers. We had the dry Cajun and blazin blue wings. They were blazing. The George Constnaza burger was delicious as well as the Blue burger. A great neighborhood spot. Friendly even for someone passing through.

I 've had two encounters with Miley 's, fool me once shame on you, fool me twice, I 'm never eating here again. My first encounter with Miley 's was when I made a phone call to place my order. I started off and asked the lady a question (rookie mistake), she gave me some vague response, so I became hesitant because she kind of left me hanging. I then asked her another question which was met with an abrupt Look I 'm really busy here, so either make up your mind or come down here and order , to which I replied Oh, yeah sure , I then hung up, and proceeded to eat somewhere where the employees know how to function in society. Her and I were on the phone for maybe 10 seconds, I 've worked in customer service for 3 years, that kind of behavior is inexcusable. A month or so later some friends invited me out to Miley 's so I figured I 'd give it another shot. I got there and ordered a diet soda, the woman server came back maybe 10 minutes later with our drinks. She was over-dramatically huffing and puffing as though she was overwhelmed, when in reality the restaurant had little to no other customers, it wouldn 't surprise me if this was the same lady that answered my phone call before. Well whatever, at least I had my drink now, so I look down to take a sip and see an old disgusting food chunk latched onto the inside of my cup. I wanted to ask the unapproachable waitress if she could take care of it, but she didn 't come back to our table for about an hour! And when she did, I finally got to try the wings that everyone is always raving about, my overall opinion: meh Miley 's has some of the most atrocious customer service in Jamestown, I 'd feel more comfortable going to The Bullfrog than placing another order at this place. I 'm sure Miley 's doesn 't give a toss about my opinion, I mean look at their employees. But sooner or later the merits of your food will be outweighed by your awful customer service (and again, the wings were absolutely nothing special). In conclusion, Miley 's just left a bad taste in my mouth.