Four Boys Ice Cream - Jamesburg

Usually, I have a good experience here, but tonight was a complete disaster. I ordered a vanilla chocolate swirl cone dipped, and the server told me they could only do a cup instead. When I suggested putting the cone in the cup, she looked at me like I was out of my mind. I also ordered strawberry ice cream, but instead, I received some sort of Dole product that didn't taste like ice cream at all. I ended up spending $15 and could only take three spoonfuls before I had to throw it in the trash.

Tasty, fresh ice cream. Never had a bad experience. My only caveat is that the portion sizes are large, so be careful when ordering, or don't be careful and just enjoy it. This is a good problem to have.

First timer . Nice ice creams . We had Italian ice (sour patch and lemon) and kids loved it ????.. we also had sandwich ice creams on a raisin cookie .. it was good . Cone ice creams were also good. Parking facility is good.. there is also a spot to eat outside . Service was ok. Wish they accepted credit cards ! Not everyone carries cash and I don?t wanna pay extra for using their atms. Overall ok ..

The ice cream here is excellent, with all of it made in-house. Be sure to arrive early, as they might run out of waffle cones. The staff is dedicated and efficient, ensuring everything runs smoothly. I can’t wait for my next visit to the area!

I visited this restaurant about an hour and a half before closing. The lights were on, the sign indicated they were open, and their website stated they closed at 11 PM, yet it was only 9:30. I waited outside with another customer, but the staff ignored us completely. After a few minutes, I finally inquired about the situation, and they informed us that they were closed. It's clear that the operating hours here are unreliable as they seem to close early. Additionally, the staff's lack of courtesy towards customers is disheartening. I would recommend avoiding this place unless they address these issues.