Mama Teresa Pizza - Ithaca

Huge pizzas and delicious mozzarella sticks! Our go-to for pizza delivery during Dungeons and Dragons night.

I was on the hunt for authentic Italian pizza since I moved to the area, and I decided to try a variety of desserts as well. I sampled the cannoli, éclair, and roasted dough, all of which were quite good. The antipasti salad was a bit on the small side, but for the price, it was fair, loaded with plenty of meat, cheese, and traditional ingredients. However, I was disappointed with the pizza; I ordered Sicilian pizza but instead received a piece of thin crust. On a positive note, the sauce was outstanding—coming from someone who knows Italian cuisine from New Jersey, I can appreciate that. I'll certainly give them a second chance. The delivery time was 45 minutes on a Saturday, which is pretty average for Ithaca.