Italian Affair Pizza And Pasta

The pizza is as good as anything you’ll find in Cape May. Great thin crust, sauce and cheese, and the staff is always friendly.

Left me on call for about 15 mins till I called back. And they don’t do what you say

Undercooked chicken, like pink in color clearly undercooked. Fine, mistakes happen, so we give them a call. The lady who answered put the chef on the phone (maybe also the manager? and the chef proceeded to tell us that he cooked them personally and that there is no way there is anything wrong with them. Well, we still have pink chicken so rather than just refund us, the chef requested we drive back to return the two chicken dishes. The lady in the front silently inspected the chicken and then took off the two chicken dishes from the original tab without a word. There was no apology for giving us the chicken undercooked, nor for questioning our integrity, or for making us return to the store with the dishes so that they may see for themselves. Very disappointed, the undercooked chicken could have simply been an easy mistake and would not have warranted this review if they had just been like “whoops I’m sorry would you like a new one or a refund.” Instead we were told that we were wrong for thinking that the chicken was undercooked and when presented with the evidence, there was no accountability or acknowledgment of fault on their end. The lady in the front was cordial, but that chef single handedly earned this review.

Almost everytime we come to Cape May, we’ve ordered from here recently as it’s delicious and the portion sizes are great. Very fresh! They delivered to the Capers on Beach Ave on Memorial Day weekend and we appreciated not having to get into the car to drive to pick up food. It was delivered timely and the food was hot! Thank you!

I ordered a chicken Caesar salad and asked for the chicken to not have any seasoning on it due to food Intolerances. They said they could not accommodate me due to the fact that all the chicken is pre cooked for the Salads. Really they could not cook me a plain Piece of chicken. That is Ridiculous and they just lost business and my family’s future orders.