Pierre's - ISLAMORADA

The food was excellent for the majority of us. However, the service was just average, and I expected more from a restaurant at this price point. They forgot one of our coffees, and one family member's steak was overcooked. On the positive side, the location of the restaurant is fantastic.

Fantastic experience! The presentation of the dishes was impressive. The Vanilla Jalapeño vinaigrette dressing on the salad added a unique and delightful twist. I really enjoyed the chicken, which was complemented by a light sauce. The key cheesecake was a standout! The wine selection was excellent, and the service was top-notch.

Pierre's offers the finest upscale dining experience in Isla. It truly stands out as a gem in the Keys, where exquisite cuisine can be hard to come by. The atmosphere is lovely, complemented by an impressive wine list and highly skilled staff, making it a must-visit for those seeking exceptional dining and willing to invest in it. We started with a perfectly crafted martini, followed by hogfish paired with a bottle of Jadot Chardonnay, and concluded our meal with a delightful cheese plate. Everything was delicious, especially the hogfish, which was prepared in a white wine butter sauce with just a hint of garlic—it was exquisite. We will definitely return!

He did it! If there is any living room and restaurant, I could be on this earth, it would be here at Pierre 's. My parents turned me to this restaurant and lounge of frequent customers here. I see my wedding reception or dinner here in the near future 100%. The French Caribbean Balinese decor will let you fall crazy into love and bring you into the most romantic mood. The Green Flash Lounge is below and must be your first stop of the evening. Come there just before sunset. They will fall in love with a splash of X-rated passion fleet in the first swallow of their tropical cosmopolitan! They offer you a cup filled with a variety of mixed nuts to crack. Listen to the lounge/down-tempo chill out music as you fall your Martini, in love, and watch the sun go down. Go outside and sit in the comfortable pasture chairs to watch the legendary Green Flash before its too late! As soon as it gets dark, be careful not to eat of the mosquitoes alive. The food here is heavenly. There is no other way to describe it. The Oysters Rockefeller is the best/freshest I ever had in my life. The hydroponic garden salad and the radish vinaigrette is the most amazing salad I ever had in my life. Freshly cultivated delicate salad, grown on the grounds! The Huffish is so fresh, flocky, fleshy and delicate and the wild mushroom orzo: I could make a meal out of it alone with the light spices and meaty exotic mushrooms. This is the most amazing, breathable, perfect paradise restaurant you could ever dream of. As soon as you have experienced Pierre, you know that heaven exists, and that is heaven on earth.

Are We in Tahiti Yet?. Ok, let me just start by saying Pierre's is kind of incredible. With the Balinesian decor and Tahitian like views of the Florida Bay, the atmoshpere is down right seductive. The food is as well. Add to that the Hemingway-esque Green Flash Bar downstairs, which is a review in and of itself, and you've got one powerhouse of a restaurant experience. You will feel very jet set and camera ready in this hip but authentic feeling get away. The food is good, and the prices reflect that. The best deal is to saunter over to one of the lounge areas in the Green Flash bar, befriend the bar maids, grab a bowl of nuts (they are addicting), order a couple of drinks with a little wood fired pizza on the side and watch the sunset. It can't get more destination friendly than this. If you are determined to dine, so be it. You will enjoy the food, but there are a few better places on the island for a fancy dinner. However, the atmosphere, views and experience of Pierre's will definitely satisfy the worldliest of island hopppers.