Sam's Gyros - Indianapolis

Sam's gyros are absolutely delicious! The tangy tzatziki sauce pairs perfectly with the tender lamb and fresh vegetables. If you’re wise enough to order it with onions, make sure to keep some breath mints handy! Their Greek salad is a delightful taste of Athens. I’d say this place, along with Greek Island downtown, are my top favorites. The owner is a laid-back guy who's always busy but eager to help you with anything you need. The restaurant has been recently renovated, making it a great little spot. It’s not fancy, but when you’re craving Greek food, it’s incredibly satisfying!

I've walked by this restaurant numerous times since I live nearby, but I finally had the chance to try it the other day. I ordered the full-sized gyro while my friend chose the half-sized version. I found it a bit odd that the full size consisted of two half pitas wrapped separately. The bread could definitely be improved; I believe the quality of the bread is crucial for a good gyro. Additionally, the cucumber sauce contained large chunks of cucumber, which wasn't quite what I expected.

Ordered from Sam's for pick up. I had a full size beef Gyro and my daughter had a chicken Shawarma sandwich. She said she would've preferred having it over rice, and she really loved the depth of flavor on the chicken. We also had an order of hummus which we loved but the bread was just store-bought bread, so it was just OK and the lentil soup my daughter loved it. I thought it needed a little more spices to it overall a delicious meal. The service when I went to pick up the the order was great. He was very helpful and quick. They were near closing time so there was only one other couple in the building. It's a relatively small place, but very clean on the corner of 54th and college. I will definitely go again.

All I wanted was a piece of baklava, but it was so dry that they should have at least offered me some water or something to go with it. I definitely won’t be ordering any other food from here, as it just doesn’t make sense to me.

I will not support this location. I wanted the Gyros with the open pita bread. I ordered from their site. I was told I needed to order via Door Dash to get the sandwich I desired. How was I supposed to know when I ordered directly through the site, and I picked it up? There are better places!