Goodfellas Pizzeria Mass Ave.

Been a good minute since I've had a good NY style pizza. This lived up to my expectations, and the breadstick was like 2ft long and taste a bit like pizza king with similar cheese dip.

Goodfellas is my usual late night go to for pizza after being on Mass Ave. They close at 3am on Saturday nights. The pizza is sold by the slice or as a whole pizza. Last night they didn't offer whole pizzas because the line was so long, and they were running out of slices. I ordered the pizza with pepperoni, sausage, banana peppers and jalapeno. It was good, but the crust was somewhat soggy this time around...not crispy enough, but still good. The staff member makes the pizzas as you're standing in like which is cool. The music at night is always good! Usually hip hop. But be prepared to stand in line for 5 minutes or so. There's seating inside and outside. There's also a bar area in the back to buy adult beverages.

Seriously delicious pizza! Went for the cheese pizza and was not disappointed. Good crisp, fresh cheese, and just the right amount of grease. Would love to live closer to this location just to eat more of this pizza all the time! Staff and bartenders were pleasant and easy to talk to. I even got to try their in house peanut butter whiskey on the house! Easy 5 stars! Shoutout barstool sports and el Prez for reviewing this place and putting it on my radar.

We dined in Friday night early Saturday. We heard great reviews about this place. They were very busy for the late hour. These people get treated horribly, we ordered 5 slices of cheese which were great by the way! The drunk guy behind us was angry because they told him it would be 3.0 minutes for a pizza! You couldn’t wait 3.0 minutes for a pizza. They handled themselves nicely explaining that we had ordered first and it was first come first serve. He proceeded to tell her she was stupid for not taking care of him!! Really. Give these guys a break! The pizza was great, drinks were great! This is our new favorite place. Staff was very friendly more so than what I would have been being treated that way!

Secret bar in the back of this pizza place is a must visit, great drinks selection, beautiful decor, chilled tunes and knowledgeable staff. Shame it is fronted by a average pizza bar!!