Goodfellas Pizzeria Broad Ripple

The food was fantastic! Authentic New York, Italian taste!! Service was fantastic!

Was refused a carryout box because they don 't have many left like I can drive back home with a huge slice of pizza and a 2ft long breadstick on a flimsy paper plate?? Let alone walk a block and a half back to my car like that. I walked out. Don 't let a 25 cent box keep you from business. Super lame

I have ordered this pizza more times than I am proud to admit, but every time I get exactly what I expected and that is a big, delicious NY-style pie! I normally go with pepperoni and jalapeño but personally love Wiseguy the Don. Taste of Naples and Nonna's Pie are both good choices as well. I picked up from this location once and while it's a super small spot, they have a counter you can sit at and the people working there are a delight!

Pizza is yummmm We went in for a late night dinner after getting drinks around town and decided to get some pizza at GoodFellas and I'm glad we did! They sold pizza by the slice and it was such a good deal considering their pizzas are huge. We also got a cup of cheese to dip the pizzas in and they were amazing. Not much space to sit at so we just stood and ate at the counter (keep that in mind). This place is great for when you're looking for something quick, cheap, and delicious after a late night out.

Work close by and everyone raved about the breadsticks but we must’ve went at a bad time because they were cold and hard : so I’m going to try another time.