Agio Mattiti A Tuo Agio - Indianapolis

After numerous visits, I've consistently found the service to be warm and gracious, the food comforting and delicious, and the atmosphere to be relaxed yet slightly upscale.

I don't see any reason to return. The service was slow, and the food was just mediocre at best. Finding street parking was difficult, and there was no valet service. There are too many other options available, so I would recommend trying a different place.

A group of four of us, each from a different decade (in our 40s, 50s, and 60s-70s), had a delightful meal on a Saturday evening before an ISO concert. None of us had dined here before. Parking was easy and convenient. The atmosphere was pleasant, though a bit noisy. The menu offered a good selection, and the presentation of the dishes was beautiful. Everyone enjoyed their meals, which included scallops with lobster sauce, spicy shrimp, and two orders of sea bass with crab. However, the red wine (served by the glass) seemed to come from a bottle that had been opened days earlier and reused—definitely a downside. Despite that, we thoroughly enjoyed our dinner and all agreed that we would love to return to Agio in the future.