Uncle Joe’s Pizza Parlour The Hamptons Institution Since 1968

It was my first time coming here and I arrived around opening with my mom. Not only was everyone so attentive and nice, especially the owner himself who shared stories with us, but the pizza is incredibly delicious! Without a doubt, my favorite slice of pizza I’ve ever had. It’s so tasteful and fantastic, and I look forward to the next time I go back! 1000% recommend! A must!! Service: Dine in

Not horrible but.... Ordered 2 pies late. I know, I know, dick move, but we were starving and I asked if it was ok first. I arrived 10 minutes early so I didn't keep them waiting. Paid my bill and threw a $10 in the tip jar since they were very sweet about making food so late. As they were almost boxing up the pies I asked for pepper flakes and cheese to go. One of the counter girls, obviously new, asked for here to get them. A more seasoned employee came over apologizing for the additional charges. .75 a small plastic container. .50 for garlic powder. .75 for cheese filled halfway. I'm talking really small containers. My buddy asked if the charge for condiments if we ate there. No, she said. So if we eat there the cheese was free but to go is .75 cents. I paid for that, but I gotta say that's obscene. It's the equivalent of getting a cheeseburger and fries to go and paying extra for ketchup. The goodwill gained by making us a pie at 9:35pm when they close at 10pm was completely lost. In fact now I was extremely annoyed. I let the young lady know how I felt, that it wasn't her and asked she tell the owner. Still bothered this morning I told the story a few times and the people listening said it was crazy too and will stay away. Stop gouging your customers... I know I'm a tourist, but there plenty of places to anting our money. Oh!!! The pizza? Meh. Not stretched by hand. Too much corn meal on the bottom. Not grande cheese. Give it a 5, on par with dominos. Won't ever be back.

I just had dinner here, Tortellini with meatballs was delicious. The Tortellini tasted like it was homemade pasta. Very nice music in the background too. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Before I even order, you have hands down, the most customer friendly ordering menu of any I have looked at! Start with not having to sign in before looking over choices and prices! And the real time wait tracker! Thank you!!!! Next time I’ll review everything else!!!

They lied about having free ice cream and still asked me for money Service: 1