Zamarelli's Pizza Palace - Grove City

Terrible pizza! You know it's bad if little kids don't eat it. an extra cheese pizza ordered and nothing about it was good. sauce was bitter, tasteless and left a greasy aftertaste. the crust tastes like a pappe, and it really didn't seem particularly cheesy. the family refused to eat it, and I bought at the end the same type of pizza from another pizza place. also the only take cash that was inconvenient. this was not even the money fee I had to pay to get the money for it. not sure why this is a 4.5 star place, maybe because it thinks sentimental worth for locals.

Let me tell you I love Zammy's. They have some of the best pizza in all of Columbus. The only downside is they haven't modernized. And this isn't necessarily a bad thing I love a classic mom and pop pizza shop. I think the lack of accepting credit cards and still taking orders on pen and paper is a little bit too antiquated. I've heard that the owners don't want to pay a 3% credit card fee or pay for a Point of Sale terminal for taking orders. As a customer and someone's whose family has been coming here for years, I would gladly pay an extra $2-3 on a pizza if it meant I could pay with a credit card. Their loyal customer base is plentiful, and some small modern changes would do wonders for their business.

Fantastic local pizza joint! They offered generous toppings and a taste better than pizzas that are $10 more expensive!It is clear that lots of local kids work here as a part time job, and you can tell it's a Grove City favorite by how many customers line up at this small shop!Note that the restaurant is take out only (there is no seating) and they only accept cash or check (no credit cards).

We always have a delightful pizza night when we order from Zamarelli's. Top notch. Reasonable pricing.

Best square cut pie I've ever had. Love the old family charm of the business. Great customer service. Affordable too.