Garramone's - Forestport

This is such a great place in Forestport!! If you like Italian and you're in the area this is your stop! Lots of yummy choices, very friendly service and a great place to see all your local friends!

Service was the worst! They were out of a lot of things and waited forever for bread and appetizers. When I asked our waitress she got all huffy, went into the kitchen and came back with our bread and Utica Greens and TOSSED the bread onto our table. We made the comment about her throwing the bread on table and she got worse. She left and came back telling us we had to leave now and they wouldn 't charge us for the drinks greens. We didn 't leave right away as we 're eating the greens and bread and finishing our drink. Then Mr Garramone comes out and tells us to leave. We were trying to explain to him that she threw the bread on table , he said I don 't believe you . We aren 't young or trouble makers. My sister is 74 my girlfriend and I 68, my son 48. I tried to say was a long time customer and been going there since 1973 with my grandfather father and he said don 't do any name dropping .Seriously not saying Harrison Ford or some famous person. Anyway we were told to leave and never come back and that he didn 't believe us. I don 't think we were the only ones that had issues that night as the table of 5 behind us only left a $5 tip Needless to say we 'll never go back

I am local resident have been going to garramones for years have never had problem, but tonight it was horrible, horrible, I wanted to punch this waitress in the head she was very rude. I understand that you are busy but it does not take 45 minutes for a meal and then we asked what was taking so long she looks at us and says we'll look around you we are busy we had been there since 600pm and it was 7pm when we walked up to the bar to pay for what we had drinks and a salad,she says thanks for coming how was your meal I said wouldn't know haven't gotten are food we would like to pay for what we had so sorry the bartender says, then the girl comes out with our food she says I have your food do you want it by this time my husband is not happy he told her to keep it. Needless to say we will not be back. So thanks for nothing it was a great anniversary not!!!!!!!!!!!!

Some of the best prime rib I've ever had. Trust me, just order it. I could do shots of the au just straight up, just the best rich deep beef flavor and just mouth watering prime rib. Garlic mash were also great.

Looking for a place to eat in the area, there aren't too many options. But the menu looked good. They had a warning sign that they were short staffed and it might take additional time, but it really didn't affect our service. Great server and everything we ate was really tasty. We had the Italian nachos (we are already talking about going back for more) shrimp Alfredo and veal parmigiana. Good sized portions, and we had plenty of leftovers that will feed us for a couple days! We definitely recommend this place, and will be taking others here. Oh! And I had a glass of wine that probably was more like two... no complaints from me on that front!