Sweetie Pies - Fish Creek

Yum! Yum! Sorry I had already taken a few bites of the strawberry rhubarb n cherry crumble! Lots of places to sit in the sun or shade! You can't go wrong with this pie!

A must stop!!! The crust is beyond amazing!! They know what they’re doing it it has no chemicals in it w basic ingredients. Read more on website. I had cherry pie and the chocolate pecan. Also took home day old cherry apple!!! Amazing!!!

I heard that this place was known for their amazing Door County Cherry Pie, and it did not disappoint! The pie was both tart and sweet, with a perfectly cooked crust and a generous filling of cherries. It would have been even better with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. However, the price was a bit high for the portion size.

I don't know where to begin with this place. First of all, it is the cutest pie shop I have ever come across. Secondly, the woman who served us pies was the epitome of sweetness, even though her name was Carol. And lastly, but certainly not least... the pies were exceptional!! The perfect balance of sweetness and flakiness. We tried a slice of chocolate pecan, a slice of blueberry peach, and 3 slices of cherry pie. Our only regret is that we didn't buy more. I would gladly drive 5 hours just to come back here and indulge in more of their delicious pies.

I was fortunate to find this restaurant with pie still available. I ordered two slices and was impressed by the generous portions, delicious filling, and flaky crust. I tried the chocolate pecan and cherry pies, both of which were excellent.