Jimmy's Pizza - Fayetteville

Last night, I ordered a 10-inch supreme pizza. At 74 years old, I've had my fair share of pizza, even while traveling in Europe. Jim answered the phone and took my delivery order. The combination of all the toppings was so amazing that I ended up eating most of the pizza by myself, saving only two slices for tonight. From now on, this will be the only pizza restaurant I’ll order from, and the price is just perfect!

The creamy Italian ham sandwich is absolutely delicious! The staff is friendly and the place is very clean!

I've had several experiences at this restaurant where I found hair on my pizza, to the point where I had to pull hair out of my throat. Also, my dad once bit into a piece of plastic, which was quite a surprise!

First time to try this place (delivery) and it was soooo good! They have mini pizzas for about $5 so if you don't know what you want- try a few! Everything we had was delicious, and our delivery guy was very polite.

This place has good pizza, it's great if you go in person and order over the counter or but what they have ready made. But I have ordered over the phone three times and it's always been a bad experience. The first time, I got put on hold for over 10 minutes and finally gave up and ordered elsewhere. The second time they got the order wrong. The third time I ordered through the Yelp app for delivery, but I made a mistake and didn't put the apartment number in. My husband called to fix the mistake and the people were very rude to him. Someone in the background was calling him an idiot and saying he was dumb for calling when it wasn't his name on the order. We'll be taking our business elsewhere.