Donnelly's Public House - FAIRPORT

First time at Donnellys and we can’t wait to return! Ordered the Buffalo chicken sandwich and it was by far one of my favorites. My fiancé got the steak bomber and it was incredible! Best one he’s had. Great service and cozy atmosphere. Be back soon!

Fantastic service and food! Annie was our server. She gave us the soup and the beer. The side order of Tot's is huge! The grilled chicken sandwich and the chicken were both fantastic! Very quick service and the food is a must try when you are in town for lunch or dinner.

Aimee, Was such a treasure for two travelers from Lancaster, We loved everything about this place, I am a cook and not one thing was out of place Here everything was so delicious when you like us and on the Erie Canal Adventures boats and have a place to stop, choose here! You need to ask for aimee of server owners, they will make your visit so special, you did our with the best recommendations, The Buffalo chicken salad was spectacular, The cheese sauce (mornay) was incredible, the tons were the best bargains for what seemed like the hundreds you got! Ask for them with the cheese sauce you cannot go wrong! The wings looked like the Turkish legs, the burgers appeared perfectly supposed, large sizes around, This will be one of the places we don't soon forget and will measure any other pub style Faire by, you put the bar incredibly high, Such a magnificent memory of this place will always stay in my heart because of the kind of service, phenomenal food, and fantastic atmosphere on the terrace, loved it! I love it! I love it! Thank you Aimee, for our visit Something that we will not soon forget, you are exactly the best kind of steward the restaurant business needs and so rarely finds, not to mention community ambassadors directly at your centrally located place for a community like Fairport, which will not forget because of the special people like you and your husband who have dedicated their lives and time to a place like this, which I hope will keep you successful in business

I was here for my birthday today and ordered the Ed B Sandwich. The beef was green and iridescent; and the sandwich was cold. I had two bites. When the waitress came back, I mentioned it. She took the dish into the kitchen and said, no worries that I will take it off the bill. She came back without a plate/sandwich, but then she told us that the beef was good and the kitchen said they couldn't take it out of the bill because there was no problem with how it was cooked. They brought the check-out with the meal that was not composed. We literally complained for a sandwich. No offer to make another court. At least I could have had the side of the Koleslawin for $15. Even if we asked for her to take off the meal, she said that the kitchen did not authorize her to take off because there was no problem with the food. You can't charge people for food they don't even have. What a funny birthday. Will never be back.

Donnelly's is a classic Irish pub friendly but low key, you can sit at the bar and chat or snag a table in the corner for privacy. The beer selection is excellent with a good rotation, and the food is also very good. This is my go to place in Fairport!