Elba House

They have great fish on fridays and a great small town vibe. Perk we live like two blocks away! Fast and friendly people who work here.

Yikes. We ended up here on a Sunday morning for a breakfast with a group and paid for the $10 brunch buffet. Included meal items were wet scrambled eggs with cheddar cheese melted on, non-crispy pre-cooked hash browns, sausage links and bacon, french toast sticks, wheat bread to toast yourself and a fruit platter consisting of cantaloupe, grapes and pineapple. It was pretty bad. The coffee was worse, weak, with the subtle undertone of bleach or some other source of chlorine. Our waitress was kind and obliged in filling my water bottle. She kept us full on bad coffee, too. Two stars for this sad restaurant, 1 for the minimum and one for good wait staff and because it's the only game in town. I won't be back.

After several recommendations, we drove from Rochester to try the Walleye. I don't know if the owners have changed, but it was one of the worst meals my wife and I had. My fish tasted muddy and had bones. My wife's fish tasted very fishy. (Both were battered. We ordered potatoes (au gratin) which were horrible. Basically sliced potatoes with melted velveeta on top. We cold not eat it. Maybe a bad night? I would not eat there again.

We were in this area for almost 2 weeks and ended up eating here 3 times. Great food and casual atmosphere. The batter on the fish is the best I've ever had. Good prices and friendly service. Love this place!

I really like this place. Totally worth the 25 min drive from Rochester. Reminds me of old style supper club, but very casual. Their salad bar is really good. Also, excellent service and reasonable prices.