Carlito’s Pizzeria - East Patchogue

This pizza is awful! It does not taste anything like Bronx pizza, but the attitude of the staff does. The man behind the counter seemed creepy and disinterested, and he was not wearing gloves. The prices were too high, so I quickly grabbed a drink and when I returned, my pizza was sitting on the counter instead of a clean surface. When I asked him to put it on a clean tray, he just shrugged and turned away. The pizza was greasy, old, and the worst I have ever had. Do not waste your time here, go to Young's on Main Street for good pizza instead.

As someone originally from the Bronx, I must say that when I tried the chicken fingers and fries, I felt a sense of nostalgia. It reminded me of being 14 years old and going to my favorite pizza place with arcade games after school. Although I had to wait a little bit for my order to arrive, it was worth it in the end. Special thanks to Savannah for her sweet and patient service, even though an apology was unnecessary.

The pizza was delicious. The staff was polite and friendly.

I wouldn't recommend if they asked them not to get. I really liked the taste, but when I found a hair 14 inches in my cake called to tell them to bring the disc I don't give them a cake. I think that's bad. I have been walking

Pepperoni roll was not cooked all the way unfortunately, completely raw inside. Disappointed. Pizza was ok