Caffe Italia - Deer Park

At the time of this review, this place had 34 straight 5 star reviews. This is the sum of this place. Great Gelato!. The hazelnut is amazing. The prices are decent. If you go to an off-time, it's kind of kozy there playing with soft Italian music. I'm a fan and I'm sure I'm back.

I just came back from Taormina Sicily and was thrilled to find a local place served gelato! I was even more enthusiastic when I saw the bride!! This place reminds me of the bars scattered throughout Italy and scooping through the cappuccino and eating my brioche with hazelnut and espresso flavor made me feel like I was back in Italy! I wish them good luck and success!!

I grew up in Italy and I can say with confidence that is one of the best places to get real homemade craft gelato. Prepared daily with fresh ingredients. A hidden jewel. Try it, you won't regret it. Best real gelato on Long Island in my humble opinion.

Quaint little place with big heart and the best Gelato hands down!!! Angelina loves it here

This place is amazing. Tastes just like the gelato I used to get in Sicily. When I walk In, I feel like I'm back in Italy