Marcello's Pizza Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I’ve given this place more than its fair share chances but it’s consistently less than a half-measure. Just scroll a few reviews and you’ll see this common theme. I feel it’s my civic duty to strongly NOT recommend this establishment based on my experience and photos. I’m also done recommending this place to friends and new residents at the war college. Play games with customers and get a honest review. Two most recent cheesesteaks from two separate orders both came out utterly ridiculous. Scroll down and you’ll see more of this. These are supposedly “extra meat”. This establishment ought to be embarrassed but this is how they send their food out the door folks. I’m done with this place.

Edit 2025: Welp, it finally happend. Got wings a few times this year and they have all been way to small for the price paid. We didn't want to give up on marcellos, we've loved supporting them, but when you're paying a ton for small wings it's a bummer. It was nice while it lasted. I have never had a problem with Marcello's. The food is always amazing and everyone there is very kind. The pasta sauce (homemade! Is absolutely amazing and the wings are wonderful. Edit 2022: everything is just as amazing if not more so. Fries are the best, Spaghetti is to die for (homemade sauce wings are the bomb, pizza is incredible. We still love marcellos, and we miss living closer to them. If they had Marcello shirts for sale I would 100% buy one Edit 2023: damn do I love marcellos, still the absolute best in everything, pizza, pasta, wings, bolis, it's all amazing. Still wish they sold their shirts somewhere, I'd wear it all the time. Marcellos is the best!

We only get to go there when we in town for Carlisle Corvette show but it is a must for us. Best of everything here and people are great.

A gem in PA. Highly recommend. Very family-orientated and the staff is excellent and very friendly.

Brought 8 friends to dinner after the first day of Corvettes at Carlisle 2024. Great food, exceptional service!