The Sugarmill, Inc. - Conyers

This family-owned business is just wonderful! Even though we arrived a few minutes after closing time, they still welcomed us with joy. The cupcakes and cookies were delicious. We will definitely be returning.

This bakery offers delicious treats. My favorites are the almond pancakes and the cream cheese brownies. However, I cannot give them a 5-star rating due to the poor customer service from the older male staff. He does not greet customers or make them feel welcome.

I ordered a birthday cake for my daughter's 4th birthday. The cake was very dry and tasteless, as were the cupcakes. It seemed as though the cake was old or had been prepared and refrigerated for too long. It was difficult to cut and the frosting had no flavor. The cake was supposed to be vanilla, but did not taste like it. The price was fair, but the quality did not meet my expectations. I do not recommend ordering over the phone. If possible, try to order in person so you can taste what you're getting. Overall, very disappointed.

My daughter and I love this place. her fave is the cookie and cream cupcakes and I love the strawberry cake. both are moist and sinful!

Thanks Sugar Mill for a very delicious and flavorful Peanut Butter Cake!! Your cupcakes are divine but my favorite is the chocolate. I love the caramel drizzle! too! And thanks for being a “real” bakery!!!