Restaurant X Bully Boy Bar - Congers

My fav place they always deliver. My fav table is always there for me next to fireplace Ribeye for 2. Cooked perfectly. Everything is so delicious and high end quality.

Food was great, service less so. Server never checked back to ask about the food. Facility was tired. Bathrooms were from last century.

Not only is Owner, Chef Peter Kelly an Iron Chef who battled Bobby Flay and won! He is a Pioneer of Rockland County having brought it their first 5 star restaurant: Xavier's in Piermont (no longer open). I can say with honesty I've never had anything at any of Peter's restaurants that I didn't love- he is definitely the most gifted chef I've ever come across and I've recently eaten twice at Thomas Kellers, The Surf Club at the Four Seasons in Surfside -not to say those experiences weren't stellar! Just saying, I think Peter has more talent. I can vouch for anything on the menu but will give special shout-outs to his; Beef Wellington with Wild Mushroom, the Grilled Cowboy Ribeye with Brown Sugar Rub, Creamed Spinach and Gratin Potatoes, the Tempura Shrimp and the Truffled Potato Puree. Absolutely, anything ordered for dessert will blow your socks off. I don't think soufflé is on the menu there but he fires up a dangerously, delicious one. Bon Appetit!

Yes, it is expensive but well worth the price. The service was fantastic. The atmosphere is fantastic. It's a quaint town, and the food was exceptional.

We haven't been here in about 5 years because our last visit was horrible. After reading some recent positive reviews we decided to try it one more time. Big mistake! The place is old and tired looking. The food is good, but nowhere near good enough to justify the outrageous prices. It's amazing that anyone would give this a 5 star review. Shrimp in the shrimp cocktail were weird looking skinny shrimp the size of your pinky. Paparadel pasta portion was so small it was comical. Tuna came out burned on the outside. Chocolate cake was grainy and flavorless. Just not a good experience and this time was out last time for sure.