O'shay's Irish Pub Eatery

I went in hoping for a couple of beers and a quick meal. When I requested a menu, the bartender informed me about their Surf Turf dinner, featuring Prime Rib and Shrimp served with Fettuccine Alfredo and steamed broccoli. I happily placed my order after a moment of consideration. However, forty-five minutes later, I received a small plate with a paper-thin slice of beef (with no question about my preferred cooking temperature), three tiny shrimp, and just a few pieces of pasta and broccoli. Everything was cold! The beef was so thin it was almost non-existent and far saltier than I could bear. To make matters worse, the owner was seated at one of the high-top tables, enjoying drinks with a friend, completely oblivious to the fact that my meal was terrible. I could only manage a few bites before letting him know I would only be paying for my drinks, and he didn’t even react to my complaint. Maybe this indifference is why there were only five other customers ordering food that night. This was supposed to be a special stop for me, and I will NEVER return.

What a lovely hidden gem! I had no idea how much this place had to offer. We visited on St. Patrick's Day and were pleasantly surprised to find out they serve dinner. Wow, this place could really become my new favorite spot—the food was incredible! The staff was incredibly friendly, making it an excellent experience. It truly felt like great comfort food!

Charming, cozy, and authentic Fenian Pub! This was an unexpected gem! There’s a small outdoor deck at the front. Our bartender, Dee, was fantastic and made us feel right at home while serving us a couple of pints. The menu features classic Irish dishes. The atmosphere truly captures the essence of an Irish pub, complete with lively Irish music playing in the background. Highly recommended; we will definitely return!

We arrived at 1:30, but Steve informed us that he didn't open until 3. However, he kindly prepared two bowls of the best salmon chowder we've ever had, along with some garlic toast. We enjoyed great conversation and a beer, and Steve was incredibly gracious throughout our visit. We will definitely be back. Thank you, Steve! - Sherry and Thumper

The food was outstanding—some of the best I've ever had—and the atmosphere was fantastic. I took my wife there to celebrate our second anniversary, and we both had a wonderful time.